We continued our discussion this week on popularity and power. We opened with a comment left on last week's entry that said:
"As for popularity, I think that maybe sometimes parents (not mine) maybe set a bad example. Not saying that all parents do, but some parents might?"
The girls then commented on ways that parents might do this. Some thoughts were:
*Parents gossiping in front of their kids.
*Parents negatively judging others based on appearance.
*Parents giving their daughters 'hints' on how to be popular.
*Parents pressuring kids to go out and be social.
*Parents buying the 'right' things to ensure their child's popularity.
*Parents putting pressure on their child to achieve.
Other thoughts? Please leave an anonymous comment.
We also talked about how sometimes when an old friend becomes more popular, she treats you differently or ditches you in public, only to act 'normal' when no one's around. There is a book in the Pine Lake Library called, My Secret Bully that discusses this scenario, as well. Many girls shared that they have had this happen and that it's really confusing. Some admitted that they put up with it, even though they don't know why they do. At B Lunch, we talked about how to handle this. Some found that it worked best to confront the friend with a question like, "Are you trying to make me feel bad?" or even a direct, "What's your problem?" Sometimes it works and the friend stops the inconsistent behavior and sometimes it doesn't work. But the point is, at least you stood up to the person, showing your own strength, regardless of the response.
So what we want to know is:
*Has this happened to you?
*How did you handle it?
*What was the outcome?
Remember, this has happened to many, many girls. It's a tough thing to go through, but please know that you're not alone.
Be strong, Sister!
12 comments:
Well, you guys seem to like my comments, so here goes!
Well, I don't really have a comment. Just a question. Has any of you people ever noticed the way teachers act towards popular and maybe not so popular people? Sometimes they seem to promote popular people and ignore others.
Well I kind of agree. In class, popular people (I am not judging people) don't pay attention. To be popular, you can't really be that smart. It's just an unwritten rule. So the teachers get really mad and give them extra attention because they need it.
As a teacher, that comment is hard to swallow. I certainly do not do that intentionally. It seems like many "popular" girls are more successful academically, and I do foster their learning. I try to foster confidence in my shy, or "unpopular" girls. I try to help everyone get along and respect each other - which is easier when the kids are younger. I have the benifit of teaching in a small community where kids grow up together, and popularity is not as important as it was for me growing up in a bigger school system.
I teach middle school students and I agree somewhat with the second comment. The very thing that makes a middle schooler "popular" is the thing that makes them harder to teach - they are outgoing and somewhat inappropriate, they like a lot of attention, they are noisy and funnier than ME. This doesn't make them smart or dumb, but it makes me pay attention to them.
"To be popular, you can't really be that smart." I think being popular comes from a kind of intelligence that involves people not books and facts, so I don't agree that people who are popular can't be that smart. I think people who are popular can be many things, and popularity shouldn't strip them of their diversity, brains, and abilities.
Sweet blog, from Mr. Ensey's class.
Yes, Anon 1 again. As for popular people tending to succeed acedemically (sp?), I don't think it really makes a difference whether (sp?) or not you're popular. And I definitley don't think that theachers do this on purpose, they just sort of start to maybe help popular people and that maybe jusst sort of evolves. Just that sometimes it is annoying to have popular people really distracting you and having your teacher having a distracting conversation with them
Hey guys!
I was thinking to coming to one of your meetings but everyone said it was to girly. I want to come but none of my friends think it is cool. what should I do
I just have one question... Why is it so hard to be popular. I mean it would be nice once in a while to try and hang out with these "popular" girls to know who they are, but they're to tight in their own circle of friends.
Is it possible to become popular? I mean after the whole A crowd has already been formed... Just wondering...
To respond to the girl who wants to come to the Sisterhood, but her friends don't think it's cool: Come anyway!!! Maybe try to get one of your friends to come with you. The Sisterhood is more feminist than girly. I hope you come. If you like to speak your mind, this is a good place to do it.
i was best friends with this girl since kindergarten and her mom used to love me. about a year ago or so one of my other friends told me that my friends mom was saying really meen things about me behind my back. now me and my friend can't hang out practically at all because here mom wont let here do anything with me.
it really hurt my feelings and now we don't even talk! i feel like just because her mom hates me that my friend hates me too. if i ask her for help or try and talk to her she gives me a dirty look or just walks away. i quess she has changed alot.
Post a Comment